BAZTEL leads the eSIM revolution with hassle-free digital SIM cards for international travelers. Enjoy automatic network selection, competitive data packages, and continuous coverage across borders. Ideal for multi-country trips and frequent flyers. Ditch the physical SIM cards forever. Upgrade your travel experience now!
Subscribe
Speed Test: eSIM vs Physical SIM – Which Is Better for Data?
Brace yourself, for mobile data is the blood that flows through the veins of our digital world. From streaming our favorite shows and keeping in touch with close people to finding our way around an unknown place and conducting necessary business on our feet, a reliable and fast data connection is not a luxury anymore, but rather a necessity. The physical Subscriber Identity Module (SIM) card has been the only way to get mobile connectivity for decades, a thin plastic chip that keeps your subscriber information safe and lets your device be connected to your mobile network. Nevertheless, a different player has appeared in recent times, and it comes with a promise of an even simpler and flexible approach: the embedded SIM, or eSIM.
An eSIM is a digital version of the SIM card that is directly embedded within your phone or other compatible devices. You won't need to insert a physical plastic card, and you will go digitally to launch a mobile plan, often by scanning a QR code or through a carrier's app. The eSIM wave is in full ascendancy with more and more modern cell phones, smartwatches, and tablets adopting this progressive feature. This usual happening of the eSIM technology sector tends to give the customer a burning need to solve some important issues for people, which is quite convenient, compared to the physical SIM. Specifically, does one of these enable higher or double saves of data in the making of the final selection?
This post is a deep dive into the features of physical SIMs and eSIMs, bringing out their use, benefits, and shortcomings. A careful analysis of the factors that have a real effect on mobile data speed and an assessment of the significance of the SIM card type will be performed. We will put the facts, tests, and real-life speed provided under scrutiny to clarify any doubts in your minds and help you in choosing better the best data transferring tool suited for your data needs.
What Is a Physical SIM?
The SIM card has had several modifications in its physical size, changing from micro to nano and mini, and eventually back to a combination of those designs through the years, all to be the number one choice of mobile connectivity ever since the old, basic mobile phones. This portable plastic card is not only the storehouse of a microchip that carries your IMSI number, of which only one is owned by your mobile network operator, but also the one that has your authentication keys, allowing your device to link to the network securely so that services such as mobile data can be accessed.
Your acquiring the SIM card from a particular mobile carrier and inserting it into your phone's designated slot are the only two steps of the process, and on powering up, your cellphone reads the information on the chip, enabling it to connect to the network.
Although physical SIMs are reliable and compatible with most mobile phones, they have some of their own advantages and disadvantages.
Advantages of Physical SIMs:
Universal Compatibility: Almost every mobile phone ever made has a physical port for a SIM card. The widespread compatibility of the physical SIMs allows them to be moved between different devices with ease.
Tangible and Easily Comprehensible: The SIM card's physical nature easily enables the end-users to understand and manage it. Changing SIMs is a straightforward operation for getting new numbers or transferring to new carriers.
Troubleshooting: A majority of connectivity issues can be solved by unplugging and re-inserting a SIM card physically.
Limitations of Physical SIMs:
Physical Damage and Loss: Since a SIM card is a physical object, it can be broken, lost, or stolen, and that would result in service disruption as well as the necessity to have it replaced.
Switching Disadvantage: It is the case that for the customer who changes the operator or holds multiple stays often it would be a necessity of perming any of the aforementioned activities by removing a SIM card and inserting another one, which is time-consuming, especially to frequent travelers or those who partly use one number for business and another for personal calls.
Device Design Constraints: The slot for the physical SIM card can affect the device's inner design, which might result in less room to accommodate other parts or in less sleek designs.
What Is an eSIM?
An eSIM, or embedded SIM, is a major step forward in mobile connectivity. The eSIM is not a physical card. It is a small chip that is fastened inside your device during the manufacturing process. It does the same job as a physical SIM – it safely stores your subscriber information and confirms your connection to the mobile network, but it does so digitally.
To activate an eSIM, instead of inserting a card, you have to download a carrier profile. This will typically include scanning a QR code from your mobile operator or using the carrier's dedicated application. After the profile is downloaded and installed, the device will connect to the network just like it does with a physical SIM.
eSIM technology has been taking off gradually with numerous smartphone manufacturers, such as Apple, Google, and Samsung, and smartwatches, tablets, and even laptops adopting eSIM support.
Pros of eSIMs:
Convenience and Flexibility: Users are very comfortable switching between carriers since they are the very settings in their devices that permit them to do so, all from their pockets and without the need for plastic cards.
Remote Provisioning: Getting a new mobile plan activated can be done remotely, which is particularly great for globetrotters who can easily make local data plan purchases upon arrival without the need for a physical SIM card.
Dual SIM Functionality: A lot of eSIM-capable devices still have a traditional SIM card slot, which provides them with the possibility of the real dual SIM experience in the sense that both numbers can be used at the same time.
Space Saving: With the absence of a physical SIM card tray, the interior of the thin devices becomes roomier, probably making it possible to accommodate bigger batteries or other essential devices.
Enhanced Security: The reflashable embedded SIM (eSIM) assures you that it is only you who, if legal, removes it and that you are protected against such risks as device loss or theft.
Cons of eSIMs:
Carrier Compatibility: Some mobile carriers don't offer eSIM support, and not all of the existing ones that do provide the technology in all areas; in which case, the users have to be especially cautious with their decision.
Device Dependency: On occasions when transferring your mobile plan to a new device requires your carrier to issue a new eSIM profile, contacting the carrier remains the most reliable and instantaneous solution, although it is not always the easiest one.
Troubleshooting Complexity: There are some rare cases of eSIM connectivity issues that are harder to handle even more than physical SIM ones.
Data Speed: What Affects It?
It’s crucial to understand that the type of SIM card – whether physical or embedded – is not typically a direct determinant of your raw mobile data speed. The speed you experience is primarily governed by a multitude of other factors related to the mobile network, your device, and your environment. These factors include:
Network Coverage: The strength and type of network signal available in your location (e.g., 4G LTE, 5G) are the most significant factors influencing data speed. A weak signal or being in an area with only 3G coverage will result in slower speeds regardless of your SIM type.
Carrier Throttling: Mobile carriers sometimes implement data throttling policies, especially for users on limited data plans or during periods of high network congestion. This can significantly reduce your data speeds irrespective of your SIM.
Phone Hardware/Modem: Your phone’s modem capabilities play a crucial role in how quickly it can connect to and utilize the available network speeds. Newer phones with advanced modems generally support faster data speeds.
Network Congestion: Just like traffic on a highway, mobile networks can experience congestion during peak usage times in densely populated areas. This shared bandwidth can lead to slower speeds for all users connected to that cell tower.
Therefore, while the SIM card enables your connection to the network, it doesn't inherently dictate the speed at which data is transmitted. However, there might be indirect ways in which the choice between eSIM and physical SIM could influence your data experience, which we will explore in the context of real-world performance.
Speed Test Comparison (Practical Results)
Conducting a controlled speed test to directly compare eSIM and physical SIM performance on the same network and device is challenging for individual users. It would ideally involve a scenario where a device supports both simultaneously and can be configured to switch between using the same carrier’s plan on either the physical SIM slot or the eSIM.
While a personal, rigorously controlled test might be difficult to execute, credible third-party sources and anecdotal evidence from users who have switched between physical SIMs and eSIMs on the same network often report negligible differences in raw download speed, upload speed, and latency.
This aligns with the understanding that the SIM card primarily serves as an authentication key and doesn't directly impact the underlying radio frequencies or data transmission protocols managed by the network and the device's modem.
Hypothetical Test Scenario (Illustrative):
Imagine a user with a smartphone that supports both a physical SIM and an eSIM. They have a data plan with a carrier that supports both formats. To conduct a test, they would:
Insert a physical SIM card from the carrier.
Use a reliable speed test app (e.g., Ookla Speedtest, Fast.com) to record multiple download speed, upload speed, and latency measurements in a consistent location and at similar times of day to minimize network variability.
Remove the physical SIM and activate the same carrier’s plan on the eSIM of the same device.
Repeat the speed tests in the same location and at similar times.
Expected Results:
Based on the technical understanding, the results for download speed, upload speed, and latency would likely be very similar between the physical SIM and the eSIM, with any minor variations being attributable to normal network fluctuations rather than the SIM type itself.
Real-World Performance: eSIM vs SIM
While raw data speed might not differ significantly, the choice between eSIM and physical SIM can impact the overall user experience in several practical ways:
Signal Stability: Basically, there is no fundamental difference as to why an eSIM would not provide better or more signal stability compared to a physical SIM. It should be noted that both the physical SIM and the eSIM are activated correctly, and the hardware of the device works well. First and foremost, the factor that decides signal strength is network coverage and the design of the device's antenna. Furthermore, an improperly installed or damaged physical SIM may result in signal disruption now and again, which is a problem that does not occur too frequently with an eSIM hidden in a device.
Roaming Performance: The common experience for eSIM technology roams internationally without issues as compared to traditional SIM cards. In addition to swiping SIM cards across the country, the users are allowed to purchase local eSIM plans digitally and activate them immediately after arrival. This act can be a great Godsend to the users, indirectly improving their data experience while using their data during travel.
Switching Between Carriers: It was earlier highlighted that moving from one carrier to another is, by and large, more easily accomplished via the built-in eSIM. Most of the time, the only thing necessary is for the users to go to the settings of the phone and download a new carrier profile, whereby the physical SIM's insertion is not at all required. People who have the habit of changing their plans very often or make use of promotional offers frequently will find this kind of flexibility very beneficial.
Activation Speed: Generally speaking, it takes less time to activate an eSIM than to physically receive and insert a SIM card. Reducing the time to complete the process is by scanning a QR code or using a carrier app that takes just a moment, from a few minutes, depending on the network, whereas waiting for the physical SIM to arrive or going to a store can be considerably longer.
Everyday Use: In the case of standard daily assignments, for example, browsing the web, streaming videos, using social media, users would not notice a performance difference upon the very act of them using an eSIM or a physical SIM, given that all other parameters (network, device, etc.) are kept the same.
Which Is Better for Data?
From the current evidence and technical knowledge, it is certain that neither eSIM nor physical SIM provides a significant advantage in terms of mobile data speed. The download and upload speeds actually depend mainly on the mobile network, the device's capabilities, and the environment as the most important factors.
Yet, looking at the full data experience, such as convenience, flexibility, and user-friendliness, eSIMs come with a set of benefits that may be very suitable for a small part of the audience:
Travelers: A simple process to change and use local data plans via eSIM without the need to switch the physical SIM card makes the technology a better alternative for people who travel abroad a lot.
Dual SIM Users: Smartphone users who have both an eSIM and a physical slot in their devices will have maximum flexibility when it comes to handling two active phone numbers for work and personal matters.
Tech-Savvy Users: If anyone is fond of technology and finds it convenient to deal with it all electronically, then most likely they will prefer eSIMs.
Budget-Conscious Consumers: The possibility of changing from one network to another with an eSIM might allow customers to have the best available data deals without resorting to physical SIMs and possibly data roaming, which in turn could be a lower-cost option.
Therefore, there is a possibility that users who stay loyal to a single carrier and only travel internationally infrequently might notice next to no difference in data experience between a physical SIM and an eSIM. Physical SIMs are still a secure and globally applicable option.
Conclusion
The discussion of eSIM versus physical SIM for data performance is centered around the idea that the type of SIM card you use is not the major factor in speed. The network you are connecting to, the policies of your carrier, the hardware of your phone, and the current network load are much more important for the quality of your mobile data service.
The thing is, however, eSIM technology (as the only trend in mobile communication) has offered better ways for people to use their mobiles. The concept is that they can easily switch networks and control multiple profiles remotely, and can even activate their plans wherever they go, thereby creating a seamless and adaptable mobile experience that is most beneficial to travelers and digital convenience seekers....
As eSIM gains traction across devices and all mobile carriers, the logical result is that it will switch from a new technology to the "norm" of mobile communication of the future.
Thinking of using eSIM? First, check if your mobile device and your network service provider support the function of eSIM. If they do, you can proceed with the activation process either on the carrier site or through the app to monitor the SIM digitally and enjoy related benefits!
WRITTEN BY
BAZTEL PTY LTDBAZTEL leads the eSIM revolution with hassle-free digital SIM cards for international travelers. Enjoy automatic network selection, competitive data packages, and continuous coverage across borders. Ideal for multi-country trips and frequent flyers. Ditch the physical SIM cards forever. Upgrade your travel experience now!
